Best Nutrisystem Meals: Our Top 7 Picks

Last Updated on

If you’re thinking about joining Nutrisystem, chances are pretty good that you have some questions you wanted answered before committing to their meal delivery program. Some of the most common questions we get, center around the food.

People often wonder if it tastes good, if it really works for weight loss, and what the best Nutrisystem meals are.

We have some pretty easy answers for those first two questions: Yes, we think the food tastes good, and it can work great for weight loss for most people who follow the diet correctly.

As for what the best meals are, a lot of that will come down to your own personal preferences. Fortunately, Nutrisystem has the largest menu we’ve found, so you’ll have plenty of meals and snacks to choose from, should you decide to join.

Keep in mind that the Nutrisystem menu has more than 160, so there are plenty of meals that taste great. With that in mind, here are our top 7 meals, and a little bit of information about each of them.

Top 7 Nutrisystem Meals for 2020

  1. Hamburger
  2. Broccoli & Cheese Stuffed Chicken Breast
  3. Chicken & Bacon Ranch Pizza
  4. Margherita Pizza
  5. Meatloaf Sandwich
  6. Roasted Turkey Medallions
  7. Mushroom Stuffed Chicken Breast

1. Hamburger

a hamburger from their frozen menu for dinner

One of the reasons that Nutrisystem is so popular is that their menu is filled with most of the classics that Americans love. The Nutrisystem hamburger is a tasty meal that pairs great with a side salad, or veggies.

Feel free to dress it up with the garnish of your choice, and you’ll have a delicious, classic hamburger to enjoy.

No frills, and nothing fancy here – just a great tasting burger that’s quick and easy to make.

Nutrition Facts

  • 240 Calories
  • 8 g Total Fat
  • 5 g Dietary Fiber
  • 14 g protein

Customer Ratings

The hamburger is easily the most popular and highest-rated meal on the Nutrisystem website. Here’s what a few verified customers had to say about the Nutrisystem burger:

I would buy this again. I have to admit that these sandwiches are very tasty. I am amazed at the microwaving process. Other products (from other frozen food companies) are soggy. Thank you. -Nikki

Well these are excellent little burgers. Load them with veggies they are real good. -Joe

2. Broccoli & Cheese Stuffed Chicken Breast

Broccoli & Cheese Stuffed Chicken Breast

Nutrisystem has several stuffed chicken breast meals to pick from, and the broccoli and cheese is easily my personal favorite. They’re savory, delicious, and if you like broccoli and cheese, then you’re sure to love this meal.

It has a great, crunch texture, and the flavor is awesome for a heat and eat meal.

Pairs great with a side of steamed veggies, or a salad.

Nutrition Facts

  • 210 Calories
  • 10 g Total Fat
  • 1 g Dietary Fiber
  • 17 g Protein

Customer Ratings

The Nutrisystem Broccoli & Cheese Stuffed Chicken Breast is another crowd pleaser, with more than 3,215 reviews, and a 4.4 out of 5-star rating at last check. Here’s what a couple of verified customers had to say:

I will buy this with every frozen order. LOVE all of your stuffed chicken breasts, they are so moist and tasty. Just wish I could have them browned just for looks. -Virginia

Order several every month! Yummy!! Add a veggie and you are set!

3. Chicken & Bacon Ranch Pizza

chicken and bacon ranch pizza

Ready for a pizza party? On most diets pizza and burgers are a big no-no, but Nutrisystem has figured out how to make them a key part of their menu, and both options taste great. Their pizza has a great-tasting crunch, golden crust, plus is topped with garlic chicken, fire-roasted tomatoes, spinach, and real bacon.

Add a layer of creamy garlic-ranch sauce, and you have yourself a personal pizza that you’re sure to enjoy.

Nutrition Facts

  • 290 Calories
  • 10 g Fat
  • 3 g Dietary Fiber
  • 19 g Protein

Customer Ratings

Nutrisystem’s pizza are some of their top-rated meals, and the Chicken And Bacon Ranch is one of their most highly-rated. Customers love the crispy crust, the generous toppings, and the ability to microwave or cook it in the oven.

We enjoyed this tasty pizza for dinner! Thanks NutriSystem for good selections! Baked in the oven for 18 minutes as suggested & it was crisp like a little flatbread with a thicker middle portion and plenty of toppings! Not skimpy at all, had lots of little pieces of chicken & bacon too. We like meat, so it was a satisfying meal. I served this alongside steamed green beans, and baby carrots I roasted in the oven with a little mustard & garlic salt. This is a definite re-order for us.

If you are craving pizza, this one is for you. Delicious.

4. Margherita Pizza

a Margherita Pizza

Nutrisystem’s take on a classic. A ready-to-bake pizza that’s crispy, tasty, and easy to make. Made with a whole grain crust, it features toppings that include mozzarella cheese, marinara, basil, and fire-roasted tomatoes.

If you’re craving pizza, Nutrisystem has you covered, and their Marherita pie is one of the best.

Nutrition Facts

  • 250 Calories
  • 6 g Total Fat
  • 4 g Dietary Fiber
  • 15 g Protein

Customer Ratings

Nutrisystem customers have given the Margherita pizza one of their highest ratings, and it’s by far one of their most popular meals. Here’s what real customers are saying about this personal pizza:

I love thin crust pizza, deep dish, hand tossed….there’s a reason I’m on nutrisystem. Pizza, the biggest diet wrecker ever, has a decent nutrisystem alternative. I always bake my dinners, so my crust was good and crunchy, done in less than 10 minutes, and better than California pizza kitchen frozen pizzas I’m guilty of consuming before my order arrived. While the frozen pizzas are cheaper, I can rest assured my nutrisystem pizza that’s twice as expensive for half as much will not ruin my weight loss plan or allow me to overindulge….and I’m satisfied with my pizza if i cut it up in quarters, eat slowly savoring it…especially once I follow up with an ice cream sandwich or tiramisu for dessert.

My most regular dinner. It’s a good little pizza. I add lots of crushed red pepper

5. Meatloaf Sandwich

Meatloaf Sandwich

I don’t know about you, but when I get the chance to enjoy some comfort food while dieting, I’m taking it! That’s exactly what the meatloaf sandwich offers – a classic comfort food, that’s delicious, but still keeps you on track with your weight loss goal.

The Nutrisystem Meatloaf Sandwich is tender, seasoned, and savory. It’s packed full of protein and fiber, and is designed to keep your diet on track.

Nutrition Facts

  • 290 Calories
  • 7 g of Total Fat
  • 7 g Dietary Fiber
  • 16 g Protein

Customer Ratings

The meatloaf sandwich is a personal favorite of PatriciaandCarolyn.com’s, but it’s also a huge hit with other Nutrisystem customers as well. It also happens to be one of the most popular meals on their menu.

Here’s what a few customers had to say about the meatloaf sandwich:

Delicious, I add tomato, lettuce and a bit of mustard.

Juicy and delicious. Very authentic taste and best of all, it is filling!

Has a lot of flavor and was very filling. One of the more satisfying dinners.

6. Roasted Turkey Medallions

roasted turkey medallions

Nutrisystem’s take on a holiday classic. Their slow-roasted turkey medallions even comes with a side of creamy mashed potatoes and gravy. Pair it with some steamed vegetables, or a side salad, and dinner is officially served.

This is the perfect diet-friendly comfort food, and one that we think tastes great.

Nutrition Facts

  • 260 Calories
  • 8 g Total Fat
  • 2 g Dietary Fiber
  • 21 g Protein

Customer Ratings

The Roasted Turkey Medallions are in the top 10 of Nutrisystem’s most popular meals, and they also happen to be one of the highest rated offerings on their website.

I did not expect too much from this because turkey and potatoes are not usually my favorite kind of meal but looking back on my first month of dinners this one is the most memorable in a good way. I wish there was a little bit more gravy because there is actually a nice amount of mashed potatoes. I ate with green beans and carrots which was perfect. The turkey is also really good and it is REAL turkey too, it had a good meaty texture and was not waterlogged, soft or spongy. I added about half a packet of soy sauce to the turkey and gravy to give the flavor a lil boost. I ordered 3 or 4 for my next shipment.

One of the best. Add some spice if you are into that and you won’t even notice you’re on a diet.

7. Mushroom Stuffed Chicken Breast

Mushroom Stuffed Chicken Breast

Nutrisystem has the stuffed chicken breast game down, so it’s no wonder this meal is a customer favorite. It’s one of their best-rated dinners, and maybe that’s because of the tender chicken, the caramelized onions, swiss and American cheeses, and a medley of button portabella mushrooms.

It’s one of  our absolute favs, and we think you’ll love it too.

Nutrition Facts

  • 190 Calories
  • 8 g Total Fat
  • 1 g Dietary Fiber
  • 23 g Protein

Customer Rating

As one of the highest-rated meals on Nutrisystem meals, most customers seem to love the Mushroom Stuffed Chicken Breast.

Here’s what a few verified purchasers had to say:

Love the taste! I microwave it about three minutes, split it and thenpop it in the toaster over to crisp it a bit! I always re-order!

I will buy with every frozen order. Delicious, moist, one of my favorites!

Summary

The foods we’ve outlined above, are just a few of our favorites. There are many more delicious meals on the Nutrisystem menu that we’re sure you’ll enjoy. With more than 160 foods to pick from, you’re sure to find plenty of meals that you love.

Resources